Automatic thoughts: meaning, examples and how to change them

CareOps editorial team · · 7 min read

Mental wellness information and service guidance published by CareOps.

About the CareOps editorial team

The CareOps editorial team publishes these guides. Sources are linked at the end of each article; examples are illustrative, not customer stories. Product descriptions refer to CareOps Maeumi. Publication and revision dates appear above.

Read our full editorial standards →

Has a friend left your message on read, and the first thing that crossed your mind was “What did I do wrong?” A short thought that appears on its own the moment something happens is called an automatic thought. It passes so quickly that it feels more like a fact than a thought, and it moves your mood and your actions along with it.

At a glance

  • An automatic thought is a brief thought that appears on its own when something happens. The idea comes from psychiatrist Aaron Beck, who developed cognitive therapy.
  • Automatic thoughts shape feelings, body reactions and behavior. When your mood suddenly drops, the first step is to ask, “What just went through my mind?”
  • The basic tool is a thought record. Write down the situation, the thought and the feeling, compare the evidence for and against, then look for a balanced thought rather than forced positivity.

What is an automatic thought?

An automatic thought is a thought that comes to mind on its own in a given situation, without any intention. In the 1960s, psychiatrist Aaron Beck noticed while working with people with depression that a fast stream of thoughts ran beneath what they said out loud, and that these thoughts were closely tied to their mood. That observation became the basis of cognitive therapy, today's cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT).

  • They are brief: a word or two, such as “I blew it” or “It's only me,” or sometimes just an image.
  • They come on their own: you didn't try to think them; they are already there.
  • They feel like facts: they move so quickly that you believe them before you can check them.
  • Each person has recurring themes: one person often lands on “It's my fault,” another on “Something terrible will happen.”

How do automatic thoughts connect to feelings and actions?

The basic picture in CBT is situation → automatic thought → feelings, body reactions and behavior. In the same situation, the feeling changes depending on which thought crosses your mind. If a late reply brings up “They must be angry with me,” you feel anxious and keep checking your phone; if it brings up “They must be busy today,” you stay fairly calm and carry on.

Automatic thoughts grow out of deeper beliefs. A long-held belief such as “I'm not good enough” is called a core belief, and a rule that comes from it, such as “I must never make mistakes,” is called an intermediate belief. Counseling usually starts with the automatic thoughts you can see, and when the same thought keeps returning, looks at the belief underneath it.

Examples of automatic thoughts

The scenes and sentences below are fictional examples written for this article.

SituationAutomatic thoughtFeeling
A friend reads your message and doesn't replyI must have done something wrongAnxiety, hurt
Your manager asks a lot of questions about your report in a meetingI'm just bad at my jobEmbarrassment, shrinking back
It's the night before an exam and you haven't finished studyingI've failed this exam, it's all overAnxiety, helplessness
A joke you made at a gathering gets no reactionEveryone must think I'm weirdEmbarrassment
You overslept this morningThe whole day is already ruinedIrritation, low energy
Your partner postpones plans because they're tiredThey must be losing interest in meHurt, anxiety

If the thought in the same scene had been “Lots of questions might mean they read my report carefully,” the feeling would have been much lighter. What needs attention is not the situation itself but taking a second look at the interpretation attached to it.

What kinds of automatic thoughts are there?

Biased thinking habits that often show up in automatic thoughts are called cognitive distortions. Several appear in the examples above.

  • Overgeneralization and labeling: judging your whole self from one event, as in “I'm just bad at my job.”
  • Catastrophizing: treating the worst outcome as if it had already happened, as in “It's all over.”
  • Mind reading: deciding what others think without checking, as in “Everyone must think I'm weird.”
  • All-or-nothing thinking: seeing anything less than perfect as failure, as in “The whole day is already ruined.”

All ten, with examples, are in our guide to cognitive distortions. Not every automatic thought is a distortion, though. Sometimes the thought fits the facts, and then it helps more to decide how to handle the problem than to argue with the thought.

How do I fill in a thought record?

A thought record is a worksheet where you pick one moment when your mood shifted and write it out in separate columns. You can fill it in that evening or the next day, once things have settled a little.

  1. Situation: one line of facts about when, where and what happened.
  2. Feeling and intensity: name the feeling and rate it from 0 to 100.
  3. Automatic thought: write the sentence that crossed your mind as it was. Mark the one that hit hardest and rate how much you believed it from 0 to 100.
  4. Evidence for: facts that support the thought. Only things you actually know, not feelings.
  5. Evidence against: facts that don't fit the thought, including ones you had overlooked.
  6. Balanced thought: write a new sentence that takes both sets of evidence into account.
  7. Re-rated feeling: rate the original feeling again and notice whether it changed.

You don't need to fill in all seven columns at first. Even just the situation, the thought and the feeling start to separate thoughts from facts. You can try the free thought worksheet without signing up, and see every column filled in on our worked thought record example.

How to change automatic thoughts

The goal is not to cover a negative thought with a positive one. “Everything will be fine” is hard to believe and rarely lasts. The aim is a balanced thought that sits closer to the facts. Try these questions one at a time.

  • Look for evidence: what supports this thought, and what doesn't?
  • Find another explanation: is there a different way to explain what happened?
  • If it were a friend: if a close friend had this thought in the same situation, what would you say to them?
  • The most likely outcome: setting aside the worst and the best, what is most likely to actually happen?
  • Behavioral experiment: choose a small action that tests the thought. For “Everyone must think I'm weird,” start a conversation with one person at the next gathering and note how they actually respond.

For example, “I'm just bad at my job” might become “Lots of questions means the report needs some work, and last month's report went through as it was. I'll list the questions and revise it.” Your mood doesn't have to be fully fine; seeing the next step is enough.

When it's hard to do on your own

When you do a thought record alone, sometimes no evidence against comes to mind at all, or the same thought keeps returning several times a day. If it keeps affecting your sleep, work or relationships, consider talking it over with a mental health professional. CareOps Maeumi is an AI counseling app that works with approaches such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). It fills in a thought record with you inside the conversation, asks one evidence-finding question at a time and remembers past sessions so the next one picks up where you left off.

Learn more about the method in our guide to CBT. Get the app

If you are struggling right now

If you are worried about your immediate safety, contact local emergency services or a crisis line where you live.

Frequently asked questions

How are automatic thoughts different from cognitive distortions?
An automatic thought is the thought itself that appears when something happens; a cognitive distortion is a biased pattern that often shows up in those thoughts. “Everyone must think I'm weird” is an automatic thought, and the habit inside it of deciding what others think without checking is the distortion called mind reading.
Can I get rid of automatic thoughts completely?
Everyone has automatic thoughts, so getting rid of them isn't the goal. The goal is to notice them when they come and take a second look before believing them as facts. With practice, the same thought tends to pull on you less.
What if I can't find my automatic thought?
Go back to the moment your mood changed and ask, “What just went through my mind?” and “If that were true, what would it mean about me?” Sometimes the thought comes as a scene or an image rather than a sentence, and you can write down that picture as it is.

Sources

  1. Beck (1963), Thinking and Depression: I. Idiosyncratic Content and Cognitive Distortions, Archives of General Psychiatry 9(4), 324–333
  2. Beck (1964), Thinking and Depression: II. Theory and Therapy, Archives of General Psychiatry 10(6)

This guide shares mental wellness information. If you are in immediate danger, contact emergency services where you are. Support and contact information.

Read next