Avoidant attachment: signs, causes and how to build closeness

CareOps editorial team · · 11 min read

Mental wellness information and service guidance published by CareOps.

About the CareOps editorial team

The CareOps editorial team publishes these guides. Sources are linked at the end of each article; examples are illustrative, not customer stories. Product descriptions refer to CareOps Maeumi. Publication and revision dates appear above.

Read our full editorial standards →

As a relationship deepens, you oddly want more time alone, and ‘what are you thinking?’ leaves you lost for words. You may only talk about a hard time once it is over, or never mention it at all. Avoidant attachment is not a cold nature; it is a way of relating in which handling things alone feels safer than leaning on someone. Here is how to keep the space you need while still growing closer.

At a glance

  • Avoidant attachment means high attachment avoidance and low anxiety. Closeness and relying on others feel uncomfortable, so you tend to step back when feelings deepen.
  • Pulling away does not on its own prove a lack of feeling. It may simply be a familiar habit of handling hard feelings alone.
  • Avoidance can change. In research it declined on average with age, and it has been proposed that it eases most through experiences of relying on someone that went well.

What is avoidant attachment?

Attachment research looks at adult close relationships along two dimensions. Attachment anxiety is how much you worry that a partner will leave or care for you less. Attachment avoidance is how uncomfortable it feels to be close and to rely on someone. Since Hazan and Shaver applied attachment theory, which began with children and their caregivers, to adult romantic love in 1987, researchers have used questionnaires that measure these two dimensions to study adult attachment.

In 1991 Bartholomew and Horowitz proposed four attachment patterns by combining how people see themselves and how they see others. What is usually called avoidant attachment is the dismissive-avoidant pattern: a positive view of yourself but low expectations of others, so anxiety is low and avoidance is high. When both anxiety and avoidance are high, the pattern is called fearful-avoidant, and wanting closeness and pulling back when someone comes near tend to show up together. Secure and avoidant attachment both involve low anxiety; they differ on the avoidance dimension.

People rarely fit neatly into one of four boxes, though. Research suggests adult attachment is closer to differences in degree than to separate types (Fraley et al., 2015), so ‘my avoidance tends to run high’ is more accurate than ‘I am an avoidant type.’

Signs of avoidant attachment

If these patterns show up often, your attachment avoidance may run on the higher side. Because it can look like independence and calm from the outside, both you and the people around you may miss it.

  • You deal with hard things alone — when a problem comes up, you only mention it once it is sorted, or brush it off as ‘no big deal.’
  • Long conversations about feelings are uncomfortable — ‘how did that make you feel?’ draws a blank, and you want to change the subject.
  • You step back as things get closer — it felt good at first, but talk of the future or seeing each other more often starts to feel stifling.
  • You go quiet in arguments — when conflict grows, you want to stop talking and be alone. To your partner, that silence can look like being ignored.
  • Leaning on others and asking for help feels awkward — accepting help makes you feel indebted, and not depending on anyone matters to you.

In a study that observed 83 dating couples while the woman waited for an anxiety-provoking activity (Simpson et al., 1992), people with more avoidant and more secure attachment differed in physical contact, supportive comments and efforts to seek and give emotional support. Attachment research sees this as a difference in how people handle difficult feelings (Mikulincer & Shaver, 2019). Choosing to hold things together alone rather than lean on someone in a hard moment is what avoidance looks like.

What causes avoidant attachment?

Attachment theory holds that how available and responsive close people have been, starting in infancy, shapes how we approach relationships (Mikulincer & Shaver, 2019). When reaching out repeatedly goes unanswered, you may learn that not relying on anyone hurts less. Experiences like these can push avoidance higher.

  • Asking for help and not being met, or having feelings shut down with lines like ‘stop crying’
  • Growing up in a situation where you had to handle everything yourself early on
  • Closing off after being badly hurt in a close relationship

Still, not everyone with these experiences ends up high on avoidance, and not everyone high on avoidance has this kind of past. The same person can also differ from one relationship to another, keeping distance from a partner while feeling at ease with an old friend.

Can avoidant attachment change?

It can. When Chopik and colleagues (2019) analyzed data from three longitudinal studies with 628 participants from age 13 to 72, attachment avoidance declined steadily with age on average. That does not mean everyone changes in the same direction, but it does mean avoidance is not a trait that stays fixed for life.

Researchers have proposed that avoidance eases most through experiences of positive dependence, that is, relying on someone and having it go well (Arriaga et al., 2018). That is why the practices below focus on small experiences of leaning on someone rather than big confessions.

Avoidant attachment in dating: the cycle with an anxious partner

Someone with higher avoidance feels at ease with some distance, while someone with higher anxiety feels settled through closeness. When the two meet, a cycle can form: the more one reaches out and wants to talk, the more the other feels pressure and pulls back, and the more they pull back, the stronger the partner's anxiety becomes.

In a study that observed couples saying goodbye at an airport (Fraley & Shaver, 1998), the way women behaved as they separated varied with their avoidance scores rather than their anxiety scores. Avoidance can show up not only in what you think but in how you act around someone close. This cycle is not one person's fault, and not every conflict comes down to attachment, but it helps to know how your stepping back lands on your partner. For the other side of the cycle, read anxious attachment signs, and for why people go quiet in arguments, see silence during an argument.

Working with avoidant attachment: five practices for closeness

The goal is not to get rid of avoidance but to learn how to take space without cutting off the relationship. Keep the time alone you need while making experiences of leaning on someone a little bigger, one small step at a time. The practices below adapt methods from cognitive behavioral therapy, acceptance and commitment therapy and emotion-labeling practice to dating situations.

  1. Notice the urge to pull back — write down the moments when you want distance, such as wanting to put off a reply or reaching for your phone mid-conversation. Note what was said or happening just before, and a pattern starts to appear.
  2. Take a break, but say when you'll be back — ‘My head's a mess right now. Let's take an hour and talk again at nine.’ Disappearing without a word and leaving a time to come back land very differently. Then make sure you come back at that time.
  3. Share a little — not a deep confession, but one sentence like ‘today's meeting wore me out.’ As you get used to your partner taking that in, the next sentence becomes easier.
  4. Name the feeling — put a single word to what you used to wave off with ‘I don't know’ or ‘nothing’: frustrated, hurt, under pressure. An emotion diary is good practice.
  5. Make one small request — start with something minor, like ‘could you look at this with me?’ or ‘could you call me on your way home?’ The point is to build up experiences of asking and finding that it went fine.
What you used to do when you wanted distanceSomething to say instead
Reading a message and not replying‘I'm busy right now; I'll answer this evening.’
Walking out mid-argument without a word‘Let's take 30 minutes and then talk again.’
Brushing it off as ‘no big deal’‘I'm a bit worn out, but I can't put it into words yet.’
Changing the subject when the future comes up‘That still feels like a lot. I'd like to talk about it bit by bit.’

Needing time alone is not a problem in itself. Simply putting that need into words so your partner knows about it can reduce misunderstandings in the relationship.

Avoidant attachment test: where do I fall?

The Experiences in Close Relationships Scale–Short Form (ECR-S) measures attachment anxiety and avoidance separately with 12 questions (Wei et al., 2007). Your result is not a verdict that you are ‘the avoidant type’; it is a map of where you sit on the two dimensions right now. Your scores can shift depending on which relationship you had in mind and how calm things have been lately. You can try it without signing in.

Try a self-assessment without signing inECR-S · Close relationshipsExplore how you relate to people close to youStart the check →

To compare all four attachment patterns side by side, read our guide to the four attachment styles.

When it is hard to manage alone

If the same scenes keep repeating in every close relationship and wear you down, or if feeling and expressing emotions has been hard for a long time, consider exploring it with a counselor. And if silence and cutting off contact are used as punishment, or there are threats or control, that is not an attachment style issue; it is a safety issue. Contact local emergency services or a domestic abuse support service where you live.

If putting feelings into words is hard, you can start by sorting through one moment at a time in a conversation.

Frequently asked questions

Can avoidant attachment be fixed?
It is not a fixed trait, and it can change. In an analysis that combined several longitudinal studies, attachment avoidance declined with age on average. Practices that gradually widen experiences of leaning on someone, like taking a break while saying when you'll be back or sharing a little at a time, can be a starting point.
Does avoidant attachment look different in women and men?
A meta-analysis of more than 66,000 people (Del Giudice, 2011) found men scored slightly higher on attachment avoidance on average, and a longitudinal study covering ages 13 to 72 (Chopik et al., 2019) also found men higher in avoidance at every age. In the meta-analysis, however, the differences were not large and varied with how and where the studies were done. What research shows is a difference in average scores, so there is little basis for a separate list of traits for ‘avoidant women’ versus ‘avoidant men.’
Does someone with avoidant attachment not love their partner?
Pulling away does not on its own prove a lack of feeling. People with higher avoidance may be used to handling strong feelings alone. Whatever the reason, though, if you keep struggling because you want very different amounts of closeness, it is worth talking about that difference in concrete terms.
How is avoidant attachment different from fearful-avoidant attachment?
Both involve high avoidance, but they differ on anxiety. With dismissive-avoidant attachment, anxiety is low, so being alone feels relatively comfortable. With fearful-avoidant attachment, the worry about being left is also strong, so wanting closeness and wanting to pull back arise together.
How should I talk with an avoidant partner?
Rather than pressing, agree together on a break and a time to talk again. ‘Think it over and tell me by tonight’ keeps a conversation going more easily than ‘answer me now.’ You do not have to absorb your partner's avoidance alone, though. Say clearly what you need as well.

Sources

  1. Hazan & Shaver (1987), Romantic love conceptualized as an attachment process, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
  2. Bartholomew & Horowitz (1991), Attachment styles among young adults: A test of a four-category model, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
  3. Fraley et al. (2015), Are adult attachment styles categorical or dimensional?, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
  4. Simpson, Rholes & Nelligan (1992), Support seeking and support giving within couples in an anxiety-provoking situation: The role of attachment styles, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
  5. Mikulincer & Shaver (2019), Attachment orientations and emotion regulation, Current Opinion in Psychology
  6. Chopik, Edelstein & Grimm (2019), Longitudinal changes in attachment orientation over a 59-year period, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
  7. Arriaga et al. (2018), Revising working models across time: Relationship situations that enhance attachment security, Personality and Social Psychology Review
  8. Fraley & Shaver (1998), Airport separations: A naturalistic study of adult attachment dynamics in separating couples, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
  9. Wei et al. (2007), The Experiences in Close Relationship Scale (ECR)-Short Form, Journal of Personality Assessment
  10. Del Giudice (2011), Sex differences in romantic attachment: A meta-analysis, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin

This guide shares mental wellness information. If you are in immediate danger, contact emergency services where you are. Support and contact information.

Read next