Four attachment styles: understanding anxiety, avoidance, and your results
CareOps editorial team · · 6 min read
General information and service guidance published by CareOps. This is not an individual diagnosis or treatment plan.
Translated from our Korean guide. Korean public services, insurance, and helpline numbers refer to South Korea. For urgent help elsewhere, contact local emergency services or a crisis line in your country.
Some people get anxious when they reply late, and some people feel suffocated as the relationship gets closer. Attachment style is the most widely known framework for explaining the difference. However, there is a much more useful way to read it than attaching a type label.
At a glance
- Adult attachment is measured on two axes: anxiety (worry about being abandoned) and avoidance (discomfort about being close). The four types are combinations of these two axes.
- Research suggests that attachment is closer to a difference in degree than a distinct ‘type’. It is not a fixed personality and varies depending on age and relationship experience.
- Use results as a map of patterns you often rely on in close relationships, not as a label that defines you.
What is an attachment type?
Attachment theory started from the bond that a child forms with his/her caregiver. In 1987, psychologists Hazan and Shaver transferred this framework to adult romantic relationships, and in 1991, Bartholomew and Horowitz combined 'thoughts about myself' and 'thoughts about others' to propose the four types that are now widely used.
Current research measures adult attachment along two axes. Attachment anxiety is the degree to which you worry that your partner will leave or like you less, and Attachment avoidance is the degree to which you feel uncomfortable getting close or leaning on someone.
4 characteristics of attachment types
| Style | The two dimensions | Common relationship patterns |
|---|---|---|
| Secure | Lower anxiety, lower avoidance | Relatively comfortable with closeness and time alone; tries to talk through conflict |
| Anxious-preoccupied | Higher anxiety, lower avoidance | Anxious about late replies, frequently seeks reassurance, and notices small changes in others |
| Dismissive-avoidant | Lower anxiety, higher avoidance | Tries to handle difficulties alone and distances when emotional conversations feel too prolonged |
| Fearful-avoidant | Higher anxiety, higher avoidance | Wants closeness yet retreats when it arrives; connection may alternate between intensity and distance |
The fourth style, often called fearful-avoidant, combines high anxiety and high avoidance. These patterns may once have served a protective purpose: anxiety tries to hold on to a relationship, while avoidance tries to prevent being hurt.
Why we need to look at two axes rather than types
A 2015 study (Fraley et al.) analyzing data from thousands of people concluded that adult attachment is a continuum of degrees, rather than being divided into different ‘types’. Most people don't fit neatly into one of the four boxes, but are somewhere in the middle of the two axes.
- 'I'm a bit more avoidant' is more accurate than 'I'm an avoidant type.'
- Even for the same person, things change depending on the other person. It may be unstable for a lover, but stable for a friend.
- Current relationship status is included in the score. A test done right after an argument is different from a test done in a calm time.
Can attachment styles change?
It changes. In a study that followed the same people for up to 59 years (Chopik et al., 2019), attachment anxiety and avoidance decreased on average with age, and people in romantic relationships had lower anxiety and avoidance. A steady relationship with a trustworthy person and the experience of counseling provide an opportunity to learn a new sense of stability.
Things you can do in your relationship
If your anxiety is high
- Dividing facts and interpretations — ‘There has been no answer for three hours’ is a fact, and the interpretation is ‘He has cooled off towards me.’ When you want to check, just put it off for 10 minutes and write them down separately.
- Make a request instead of a criticism — It is easier to get what you want by saying “I feel safe if you call me once in the evening” rather than “Why don’t you contact me?”
- Increase your pillars outside the relationship — The more places you can lean on, such as friends, work, or hobbies, the less swayed you are by one person's reactions.
If avoidance is high
- One sentence before walking away — “I can’t figure it out right now. Let’s talk again in an hour.” Disappearing without a word and leaving a time to return have completely different effects on the other person.
- Starting with a small request — Practicing leaning starts with a small request.
- Name your emotions — Write down your feelings that you used to dismiss as ‘I don’t know’ in one word. Emotion Diary is a good exercise.
If your partner is avoidant
The more you push, the more the other person retreats. This cycle of one side chasing and the other avoiding is called the ‘demand-withdrawal pattern’ in research. Rather than demanding an answer right away, arranging a time to talk again is the starting point for breaking the loop. The detailed method is summarized in the article People who don't talk when they fight.
What should not be explained by attachment type
Verbal abuse, threats, surveillance, and violence do not happen ‘because you are an avoidant type’ or ‘because you are an anxious type.’ If that happens, take safety first rather than trying to fix your attachment. You can call the women's emergency number 1366 or the police 112 for help.
Where do my attachment patterns fall?
The Experiences in Close Relationships Scale (ECR-S) is a 12-item questionnaire that measures two axes: anxiety and avoidance. The results are not a determination of ‘what kind of person you are’, but rather show which side you are leaning towards. You can try it right away without logging in.
Try a self-assessment without signing inECR-S · Close relationshipsExplore how you relate to people close to youStart the check →Frequently asked questions
- If an attachment style is determined at a young age, does it last a lifetime?
- No. Childhood experiences are the starting point, but in studies that followed for decades, attachment anxiety and avoidance, on average, decreased with age and varied with relationship experience.
- Why is it difficult when the anxious and avoidant types meet?
- The more anxious one gets, the closer they get, and the more burdensome the other gets, the more they withdraw, and each party's reactions increase the other's anxiety. It's not about who is bad, it's a matter of links, so it can make a difference if you decide the break time and return time together.
- Are attachment style tests reliable?
- The reliability of the scale used in the study has been confirmed, but since it is a self-answer test, it is affected by your current mood and relationship status. Use this not as a diagnosis, but as a starting point for understanding yourself.
- Is there a problem if it is not stable?
- No. Anxiety and avoidance exist to some degree in everyone, and there is only a difference in degree. Because of its method, it is worth looking into when the same difficulties recur in a relationship.
Sources
- Hazan & Shaver (1987), Romantic love conceptualized as an attachment process, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- Bartholomew & Horowitz (1991), Attachment styles among young adults: A test of a four-category model, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- Fraley et al. (2015), Are adult attachment styles categorical or dimensional?, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- Chopik, Edelstein & Grimm (2019), Longitudinal changes in attachment orientation over a 59-year period, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- Wei et al. (2007), The Experiences in Close Relationship Scale (ECR)-Short Form, Journal of Personality Assessment
This article provides general information, not diagnosis or treatment. For urgent help, contact local emergency services or a crisis line in your country. In South Korea, the suicide prevention helpline is 109 (24 hours), and the mental health crisis line is 1577-0199.