When thoughts keep looping: understanding worry and rumination
CareOps editorial team · · 7 min read
General information and service guidance published by CareOps. This is not an individual diagnosis or treatment plan.
Translated from our Korean guide. Korean public services, insurance, and helpline numbers refer to South Korea. For urgent help elsewhere, contact local emergency services or a crisis line in your country.
Why did he say what he said earlier, and what did he mean? I've been thinking about the same thing for hours, but I can't find an answer and I just feel drained. It's not a fault to think too much. However, you need to distinguish whether your thoughts are moving forward or going around in place.
At a glance
- Repeating the same thoughts over and over again without resolution is called rumination. It may feel like you're solving a problem, but in reality, it just dampens your mood and delays the solution.
- The key to stopping is not suppressing your thoughts, but changing ‘why’ to ‘what and how’ and shifting your attention to your body and outside.
- People who walked in nature for 90 minutes had less rumination. Moving your body is often the fastest way.
Rumination Meaning: How is it different from worry?
Rumination comes from the meaning of a cow chewing its cud over what it ate. In psychology, it refers to passively thinking over and over again about difficult tasks, their causes, and results. Nolen-Hoeksema, who led the rumination research, concluded that rumination makes depressed mood longer and deeper, interferes with problem solving, and wears out support from those around you.
| Problem-solving | Rumination | |
|---|---|---|
| Question | What can I do? | Why am I like this? Why did they do that? |
| Direction | Moves toward a next action | Circles the same point |
| Afterward | One thing to try | More tired or low |
| An endpoint | Yes | Often no |
Worry is a related pattern. Worry usually focuses on what might happen in the future, while rumination usually focuses on what has already happened. Ways of responding overlap because both involve recurring thoughts.
A loop that many thoughtful people fall into.
- Rumination feels like insight. I keep holding on to the feeling that ‘if I think about it a little more, I’ll know why.’ But an hour later, I'm still in the same spot.
- It starts in the wee hours. In a study (Killingsworth & Gilbert, 2010) that asked 2,250 adults about their daily lives on their smartphones, people spent 46.9% of their waking time thinking about things other than what they were currently doing, and when they did, they were less happy.
- The lower your mood, the worse it gets. A depressed mood leads to rumination, and rumination brings the mood down further.
- The more you suppress it, the more it comes back. If you try not to think about it, you will keep looking at it, and it will come back to you more often.
Six ways to stop rumination
1. Change ‘why’ to ‘what and how’
‘Why am I always like this?’ is a question that has no answer. There is an answer to the question, ‘What will my first words be if the same situation comes next time?’ Watkins (2008), who studied recurring thoughts, summarized that when you think about the specific ‘how’ rather than the abstract ‘why’, the same topic is helpful rather than harmful.
2. Address yourself by name
Instead of ‘Why did I do that?’ try calling yourself by your name, like ‘Jihyun, what’s bothering you the most right now?’ In several experiments (Kross et al., 2014), people who spoke to themselves by their own name or 'you' were less distressed and ruminated less afterward than those who spoke with 'I'. Just like when I look at a friend's work, I look at it from a step away.
3. Set aside time to think
I decide to think as much as I want for 30 minutes once a day, at the same time and in the same place. If it comes up at another time, I put it off and say, ‘Let’s do it at 7 p.m.’ It's not a ban, it's a reservation. People who used this method spent less time worrying during the day (Borkovec et al., 1983).
4. Moving attention to the body
It's difficult to stop thinking with your thoughts. In one experiment (Bratman et al., 2015), people who walked in nature for 90 minutes experienced less self-perceived rumination, and activity in brain areas related to rumination also decreased. There was no such change in people who walked downtown. I also like things that involve distinct bodily sensations, such as taking a walk in a nearby park, washing dishes, or taking a shower.
5. Put it down on paper and finish with one action:
I write down the thoughts that are spinning in my head. If you write it down, you can clearly see that the same sentences are being repeated. And at the bottom, write 'So, one thing you can do now' and close it. If there is nothing you can do, the answer is to write 'There is nothing I can do right now.' You can also use the four-line form in Emotion Diary.
6. Notice and return
When you notice rumination beginning, name it—“I am ruminating again”—and return your attention to what you were doing. If the thought returns 20 times, redirect your attention 20 times. The practice is returning your attention, not making thoughts disappear.
When you have a lot of thoughts at night
Daytime activities occupy your attention, but thoughts you put aside can return when the lights go out. Try method 3 above—scheduled thinking time—earlier in the evening. If you toss and turn for more than about 20 minutes, get up and move to another room. See our guide to racing thoughts before sleep.
When it's difficult to handle alone
If rumination takes up most of your day and your depression or anxiety deepens, seek counseling or medical attention. If unwanted thoughts come in and you repeat checking or rituals to erase them, it may be obsessive-compulsive symptom. If you find yourself thinking 'I want to disappear', you can call the suicide prevention hotline at 109 (24 hours a day) to talk now.
Frequently asked questions
- Is it your natural personality to think a lot?
- The tendency to think deeply is influenced by temperament. That in itself is also an advantage. What you need to look at is not the amount of thoughts, but whether those thoughts lead to the next action or stay in the same place. Spinning thoughts can be reduced with practice.
- If I try not to think about it, it gets worse. What should I do?
- If you suppress a thought, you will keep checking to see if that thought occurred, so it will come back to you more. Rather than trying to get rid of it, notice what comes up and then shift your attention to the sensations in your body or what you were doing. Leave your thoughts alone and just shift your attention.
- What is the difference between rumination and worry?
- Rumination is mainly thinking about what has already happened and why, while worry is thinking about what may happen in the future. They both have the same thoughts going around without resolution, so the ways they deal with them overlap.
- Is there a connection between thinking too much and depression?
- Rumination is known to make depressed mood longer and deeper. Just because you think a lot does not mean you are depressed, but if lethargy and loss of interest along with rumination persist for more than two weeks, check out Early Symptoms of Depression.
Sources
- Nolen-Hoeksema, Wisco & Lyubomirsky (2008), Rethinking Rumination, Perspectives on Psychological Science
- Watkins (2008), Constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought, Psychological Bulletin
- Kross et al. (2014), Self-talk as a regulatory mechanism: How you do it matters, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- Bratman et al. (2015), Nature experience reduces rumination and subgenual prefrontal cortex activation, PNAS
- Killingsworth & Gilbert (2010), A Wandering Mind Is an Unhappy Mind, Science
- Borkovec et al. (1983), Stimulus control applications to the treatment of worry, Behavior Research and Therapy
This article provides general information, not diagnosis or treatment. For urgent help, contact local emergency services or a crisis line in your country. In South Korea, the suicide prevention helpline is 109 (24 hours), and the mental health crisis line is 1577-0199.